
Tenant Satisfaction Surveys: How to Measure and Act
February 18, 2026

A lease renewal pipeline review is a mid-year pass over every tenant whose lease ends in the next 12 to 18 months, scoring each one on how much you want to keep them and how likely they are to leave. Do it now, while there is still time to fix what is bothering them, rather than when the lease enters its last few months and the tenant has already made up its mind.
The facility manager's part is specific: you hold the complaint history, the work order record and the day-to-day relationship that leasing and ownership rarely see. This guide covers how to build the risk list, which operational signals matter, how to open early conversations, and how to keep facilities, leasing and ownership working from the same page.
Because tenants decide on accumulated experience, and mid-year is the last point where you can still change that experience before most renewal clocks start running. A tenant that has lived with a failing restroom, a slow response to a ticket or a lobby that looks tired for a year does not forget it when the broker calls.
The research backs the link between experience and renewal. A working paper from MIT's Center for Real Estate, built on tenant surveys covering 2,906 U.S. office buildings, found that a 1-point increase in tenant satisfaction on a 5-point scale is associated with an 8.6% higher willingness to renew, an 11.5% higher likelihood of recommending the property and a 14.6% lower probability of moving out (Hu, Kok and Palacios, SSRN, January 2024). These are associations in survey data, not guarantees, but they point in one direction.
The authors also report that satisfaction matters most for short-term tenants and in submarkets with high vacancy (AEA conference version). Silicon Valley has been tightening: Kidder Mathews put office vacancy at 15.9% in the third quarter of 2026, down 160 basis points from a year earlier (Kidder Mathews). That is still a market where a tenant with a short remaining term has options. Brokers measure vacancy differently, so check your submarket's number with the source your owner uses.
List every lease ending in the next 18 months in date order, then score each tenant on two questions: how much does the building want to keep them, and how likely are they to go. Keep the scoring simple enough that three people would score the same tenant the same way.
For the first question, leasing and ownership usually lead. Square footage, rent against market, remaining term and the tenant's credit and growth outlook all count. So does a recognizable tenant whose presence helps you lease to others.
For the second question, facilities has the best evidence. Pull these from your own records:
Sort the result into three groups: keep warm, intervene now and watch. A high-value tenant with repeat complaints goes straight to intervene. Do not build a spreadsheet nobody reads; a one-page list that three people review monthly beats a model nobody updates.
The ones that interrupt their workday and recur. BOMA International's Q4 2025 operations paper says tenants surveyed that year report that building upkeep and quality are increasingly factors in their renewal decisions, particularly for office and medical occupants. It adds that an unreliable HVAC system, a leaky roof or persistent plumbing issues can be "push" factors that convince tenants to relocate (BOMA, The High-Performance Blueprint for Modern Building Operations).
The same paper cites the 2025 Kingsley Index Report for the finding that building-related factors such as HVAC, parking and building quality are catching up with management service delivery as drivers of overall satisfaction. Service still matters, but the physical building now counts for more than it did.
For a facility manager, that translates into a short list to check against each at-risk tenant's suite and floor:
Fixing one chronic issue for a tenant you are about to lose is a better use of money than a lobby refresh the tenant never sees.
Earlier than the lease calendar demands, and framed around the tenant's business, not the lease. For the tenants on your intervene list, a low-pressure check-in a year or more before expiration gives you time to hear a space change coming, whether growth, contraction or a move, while you can still offer a solution inside the building.
Keep the first conversation off price. Ask how headcount is trending, how their hybrid schedule is working, whether the current layout still fits and what has been frustrating about the building. Then act on what you hear and report back. A check-in that produces no visible change teaches the tenant that feedback goes nowhere.
For tenants with a known grievance, bring a specific remediation plan to the conversation, with an owner and a date. If the fix is a larger project, such as a suite refresh, a layout change or a phased move to different space, coordinate it with leasing early so it is approved before it becomes a negotiating chip. This is where a facility management partner earns its place: planning the work, scheduling vendors around the tenant's calendar and following through. For changes inside the building, MAFM's facility management team plans and coordinates this kind of work and the vendors behind it.
Look at it from the tenant's side: what would they see if they toured the alternatives? Ask your leasing team and brokers which nearby buildings are winning deals and why, and review current asking rents and concessions in your submarket through the reports your ownership already uses. Rates and vacancy differ by submarket and by broker, so use the same source consistently over time.
Compare services as well as price. Tenants weigh cleanliness, responsiveness, amenities and how the building feels to arrive at. If you are building a tenant experience program, our post on tenant experience and lease renewals covers the program side.
Operational standards can also be a credible proof point. BOMA's BOMA 360 Performance Program evaluates buildings in six areas, including building operations and management, life safety, training, energy, sustainability and tenant relations. BOMA says independent Kingsley and CoStar studies found higher satisfaction and retention among designated buildings. That is BOMA's own description of its program, so treat it as one input, not proof that a designation will keep a tenant.
Share the risk list. Leasing sees rent, term and market; facilities sees whether the tenant is happy day to day. Neither view is enough on its own, and tenants notice when the two give different answers.
Agree on a few ground rules before the renewal season gets busy:
Track results against your own history, such as your 2025 renewal outcomes, instead of an outside benchmark you cannot verify. If the interventions are working, the repeat-complaint count and the days to close should both fall, and that will show before the renewals do.
How far ahead of lease expiration should we review renewals? List every lease ending within 12 to 18 months and review the list monthly. Start conversations with high-value, high-risk tenants as early as that list justifies, because the point is to fix problems while a fix can still change the decision. There is no sourced standard for the exact timing, so set it by tenant, not by a universal rule.
Does tenant satisfaction really affect renewals? Research suggests so. The MIT Center for Real Estate working paper found that each 1-point increase in satisfaction on a 5-point scale is associated with 8.6% higher willingness to renew and a 14.6% lower probability of moving out. It is survey-based and shows association, so use it as a reason to measure and respond, not as a forecast for a single tenant.
What should a facility manager bring to a renewal strategy meeting? Bring the work order and complaint history for each tenant on the list, how long issues took to resolve, which problems recur and what each fix would cost and take to schedule. Leasing has the rent and term. Facilities has the evidence of how the tenant actually experiences the building.
Can a facility management company help with renewal preparation? Yes, with the operational side. A partner like MAFM can run the walkthroughs, track recurring issues, plan and schedule fixes and coordinate vendors. Lease terms and pricing remain with your leasing team and ownership.
If your risk list shows repeat complaints about cleanliness, response times or building condition, that is work a facility partner can plan and schedule. MAFM serves Silicon Valley buildings from San Jose; talk to us about facility management and we will walk the building with you.
MAFM offers comprehensive facility management solutions tailored to your business needs.
Get in Touch